The OIG is reviewing who pays for drugs during Part A stays. See your exposure in 48 hours →

How to dispute a pharmacy invoice (with a letter template)

How a nursing home can dispute a pharmacy invoice: the evidence each finding needs, a step-by-step process, and a plain-text dispute letter template.

Get a free 48-hour audit Estimate your savings

To dispute a pharmacy invoice, a nursing home should send the pharmacy a written notice, inside the dispute window in its pharmacy services agreement, that lists each disputed line with the invoice reference, the amount, the reason, and the evidence: the contract clause, the census record or the order. Pay the undisputed balance on time, ask for a credit memo by a set date, and track the credit until it posts. A precise, documented dispute is resolved faster than a general complaint about the bill.

What does your contract say about disputes?

Start with the agreement, because it sets the rules you will be held to. Most pharmacy services agreements include a billing or payment clause that covers:

  • The dispute window: how many days after the invoice date you have to raise a dispute. Late disputes may be refused.
  • The format: written notice, sometimes with specific detail required.
  • The address: who receives disputes, often a named billing contact or a legal notice address.
  • Payment of undisputed amounts: many agreements require you to pay the undisputed portion on time.
  • Resolution and escalation: a period for the pharmacy to respond, and a path if you disagree, such as executive review, mediation or arbitration.

If you cannot find a dispute clause, look for "billing," "payment terms," "notices" and "audit rights." Our guide to pharmacy services agreement terms explains where these usually sit.

What evidence does each type of finding need?

A dispute line is only as strong as the document behind it. The table shows what to attach for the most common findings.

FindingInvoice evidenceSupporting evidence
Wrong payer (not a Part A day)Line with payer code and dispense dateCensus showing the resident's payer on that date
Charge after discharge, death or leaveLine with dispense dateCensus discharge, death or leave record
Duplicate or overlapping fillBoth lines, with days supplyOrder history showing no dose change
Missing creditOriginal charge lineReturn manifest signed by the pharmacy
Fee not in contractFee lineFee schedule from the agreement
Price above contractLine with NDC and unit priceContract pricing formula and reference price for the date
Excluded drug billed for a Part A residentLine with drug and dateCMS consolidated billing category for that drug

Resident information is protected health information. Send it only to the pharmacy you contract with, which already holds it, use resident ID numbers instead of names where the pharmacy can match them, and use a secure channel.

What could your building recover?

Two numbers, instant estimate. No email needed.

Estimated recoverable per year$0
See your full estimate Planning estimate for one building at 85% occupancy. How it works

How do you dispute a pharmacy invoice, step by step?

  1. Read the dispute clause. Note the window, the format, the address and any rule on paying undisputed amounts.
  2. Finish your review of the invoice. Use our nursing home pharmacy invoice audit checklist and line-by-line guide to an LTC pharmacy invoice to find the lines.
  3. Build a findings schedule. One row per disputed line: invoice number, line or Rx number, resident ID, dispense date, drug, amount, reason, and the evidence reference.
  4. Total it. Show the disputed total and the undisputed balance.
  5. Write the letter. Use the template below. Keep the tone factual.
  6. Pay the undisputed balance on time, if your agreement requires it.
  7. Send it the way the contract requires, and keep proof of delivery.
  8. Track the response. Log each line as accepted, rejected or pending. Ask for a reason for each rejection.
  9. Confirm the credit. Tick off each accepted line when the credit posts. See our guide to pharmacy credits and returns.
  10. Escalate if needed, using the path in the agreement. For large amounts, talk to your healthcare attorney before escalating.

What if the correction increases your bill?

Some findings run the other way. If a drug for a resident in a covered Part A stay was billed to the resident's Part D plan, Part D should not have paid. CMS states that drugs for a Part D enrollee are not covered by Part D if Part A or Part B can pay (MLN fast facts). The OIG estimated up to $465.1 million in such improper Part D payments from 2018 through 2020, and recommended that CMS instruct facilities to cooperate with plan sponsors to identify and prevent them (OIG A-09-21-03008).

Correcting this usually means the pharmacy reverses the Part D claim and bills your facility. Treat it as a compliance correction, not a dispute, and get advice from your compliance officer or counsel. Our article on the OIG's review of SNF drug billing explains why this matters now.

A pharmacy invoice dispute letter template

Copy the text below, replace everything in square brackets, and attach your findings schedule. Adapt it to the notice terms in your agreement. This template is not legal advice; for significant amounts or contested terms, have your attorney review it before sending.

[Facility letterhead]

[Date]

[Pharmacy name]

Attn: [Billing contact or notice address named in the agreement]

[Address]

Re: Billing dispute, invoice(s) [invoice numbers], [facility name], account [account number]

Dear [Name],

Under section [section number] of our Pharmacy Services Agreement dated [date], we are disputing the charges listed in the attached findings schedule, totaling $[disputed total], on the invoice(s) referenced above.

For each line, the schedule shows the invoice and Rx number, resident ID, dispense date, drug, amount, the reason for the dispute and the supporting document. The reasons fall into these categories:

[Number] lines billed to the facility for dates on which the resident was not in a covered Medicare Part A stay, per our census.

[Number] lines dispensed after the resident's discharge, death or leave, per our census.

[Number] duplicate or overlapping fills.

[Number] credits due for returned medication that have not posted.

[Number] fees or prices that do not match the agreement, section [section number].

We have paid [or will pay by (date)] the undisputed balance of $[amount].

Please issue a credit memo for the disputed amount, or a written explanation for any line you do not accept, by [date, for example 30 days from this letter]. Please reference the line numbers in our schedule so we can reconcile your response.

Resident information in the attachment is protected health information, provided for billing and payment purposes only.

Please direct questions to [name, title, phone, email].

Sincerely,

[Name]

[Title]

[Facility name]

Attachment: Findings schedule ([number] lines)

This article is general information, not legal advice.

Free · 48 hours · no integration

Get a free 48-hour pharmacy audit

  • Send three files: invoices, census, contract
  • See overbilling and Part A exposure, line by line
  • BAA signed before any data moves

Frequently asked questions

How long does a nursing home have to dispute a pharmacy invoice?

As long as the dispute window in your pharmacy services agreement allows. Many agreements set a short period after the invoice date. If yours is short, review invoices monthly so findings do not age out.

Should a nursing home withhold payment while disputing a pharmacy bill?

Check your agreement first. Many require the undisputed portion to be paid on time, and withholding the whole invoice can put you in breach or trigger late fees. Paying the undisputed balance keeps the focus on the disputed lines.

What if the pharmacy rejects the dispute?

Ask for a written reason for each rejected line and compare it with the contract and your evidence. If you still disagree, use the escalation path in the agreement. For large or contested amounts, involve your healthcare attorney.

Do I need a lawyer to dispute a pharmacy invoice?

Not for routine line-item disputes backed by clear evidence. Bring in counsel for large amounts, contract interpretation questions, anything touching Part A and Part D payment corrections, or when the pharmacy refuses to engage. If you advise nursing homes on these questions, see how we work with advisors and partners.

Get the 48-hour first look

Send three months of invoices, your census and your pharmacy services agreement. We find the lines worth disputing and, in a full audit, give you a dispute package for each finding: invoice lines, census evidence, contract clause and a draft letter. Start with the free 48-hour audit or the savings calculator.