The pharmacy audit cost for a nursing home depends mostly on the pricing model, not the firm: an in-house review costs staff time, audit software costs a subscription plus staff time, recovery-fee firms take a share of what they recover, and flat-fee firms charge a set price per building. Pennywell charges a flat $5,000 per building for a full audit, after a free 48-hour first look, and $1,000 per building per month for ongoing monitoring. The fair comparison is total cost against what each model will actually find, document and fix.
What are the ways to pay for a pharmacy audit?
A nursing home pharmacy audit is a line-by-line check of the pharmacy's invoices against the facility's census, its pharmacy services agreement and the payer rules, to find charges the facility should not pay. The work is the same whoever does it. What changes is how you pay for it.
| Model | How you pay | What drives the cost | Question to ask |
|---|---|---|---|
| In-house review | Staff salaries | Hours spent per invoice cycle | Who covers the work when that person is out or leaves? |
| Audit software | Subscription, often plus setup | Users, buildings, integration | Who on your team runs it and works the exceptions? |
| Recovery-fee (contingency) firm | A share of money recovered | Size of the recoveries | What counts as a "recovery," and for how long? |
| Flat-fee firm | A set price per building or per month | Number of buildings | What exactly is included, and what is extra? |
A fifth option, a review run by your own pharmacy, usually carries no separate fee because it is bundled into the pharmacy contract. It is not independent of the bills it reviews, which is the reason most operators look outside. Our comparison of pharmacy audit options covers that trade-off in detail.
Why does the audit cost matter most on the Part A line?
For residents in a covered Medicare Part A stay, drugs are part of what the daily rate pays for under SNF consolidated billing. The pharmacy bills the facility, and every overbilled dollar comes straight out of margin. Our guide on who pays for drugs during a Part A stay explains the rules.
As a planning figure only (a Pennywell estimate, not a result), we assume facility-paid drug spend of $250,000 to $500,000 per building per year, with about 10% recoverable. That is $25,000 to $50,000 a year per building. Your number could be higher or lower. The point is that the audit fee should be small next to what it finds.
What could your building recover?
Two numbers, instant estimate. No email needed.
How do flat-fee and contingency pricing compare?
A contingency fee (also called a recovery fee) is a payment equal to a share of the money a firm recovers for you. A flat fee is a fixed price set before the work starts. Both are legitimate. Each has an honest trade-off.
Contingency pricing. If the audit finds little, you pay little. That is a real advantage when you have no idea whether a problem exists. The cost is that the fee grows with every dollar found, and the firm is paid most for the findings that turn into cash quickly.
Flat pricing. You know the cost before you start, and you keep everything you recover. The risk is paying the fee and finding little. A free first look addresses that risk: you see the findings before you pay anything.
One structural point deserves attention. Some of the most important findings are not recoveries at all. If a drug given during a Part A stay was billed to the resident's Part D plan, the fix may mean the facility pays for it, not gets paid. The OIG estimated that Part D paid up to $465.1 million in 2018 through 2020 for drugs that payment was available for under the Part A SNF benefit (OIG report A-09-21-03008). A fee tied only to recoveries has no natural way to pay for finding that exposure. Ask every provider how they handle it.
Illustrative example. The table shows what a flat $5,000 fee equals as a share of recoveries at different recovery levels. These are arithmetic, not results.
| Recovered in the year | $5,000 flat fee as a share of recoveries |
|---|---|
| $10,000 | 50% |
| $25,000 | 20% |
| $50,000 | 10% |
| $100,000 | 5% |
Compare those percentages with the share in any contingency proposal you receive. Where the line crosses depends entirely on how much your building has to recover.
What does Pennywell charge, and what is included?
Our pricing is published on the pricing page and is the same for every client.
- Free 48-hour first look. Three months of invoices, your census and your pharmacy services agreement. A report of overbilling and Part A exposure, ranked by dollars, plus a 30-minute walkthrough.
- Full audit: $5,000 per building. A dispute package for each finding: the invoice lines, the census evidence, the contract clause and a draft dispute letter. Waived for operators with two or more buildings on monitoring.
- Monitoring: $1,000 per building per month. Every invoice line checked each month, credits tracked until they arrive, and a client dashboard. Cancel any month.
We take no percentage of recoveries and no money from pharmacies or manufacturers. A HIPAA business associate agreement is signed before any data moves.
Illustrative example. A single building that takes the full audit and then a year of monitoring pays $5,000 plus $12,000, or $17,000. A three-building operator on monitoring pays $36,000 a year, with the audit fees waived.
What hidden costs should you count?
- Staff time. An in-house review is never free. Someone has to pull invoices, match census and chase credits every month.
- Setup. Software often needs data feeds or configuration before it produces anything.
- Dispute work. A finding is worth nothing until someone sends the dispute and tracks the credit. Ask who does that. With Pennywell, your team sends disputes using our package; we track whether credits arrive. Our guide on how to dispute a pharmacy invoice shows the process.
- Fee tails. With any share-based fee, ask whether it applies only to past overcharges or also to future savings from contract changes, and for how long.
- Data handling. Any outside reviewer will see protected health information. Require a business associate agreement first.
How do you compare pharmacy audit quotes?
- Write down the scope. Which invoices, which months, which buildings, which checks (payer, discharge, duplicates, fees, price).
- Ask for the total cost in dollars for one year, under realistic assumptions, from every provider.
- Ask how compliance findings are handled when they produce no recovery.
- Ask who drafts and sends disputes, and who tracks the credits.
- Ask what you receive as evidence: invoice lines, census records and contract clauses, or only a summary.
- Confirm independence. Does the provider take money from pharmacies or manufacturers?
- Check the exit. Notice periods, minimum terms and any fee that survives cancellation.
For a single-building operator, see how this plays out for independent nursing homes. For groups, the economics change with scale; see regional operators.
Free · 48 hours · no integration
Get a free 48-hour pharmacy audit
- Send three files: invoices, census, contract
- See overbilling and Part A exposure, line by line
- BAA signed before any data moves
Frequently asked questions
How much does a nursing home pharmacy audit cost?
It depends on the model. In-house reviews cost staff time, software costs a subscription plus staff time, contingency firms take a share of recoveries, and flat-fee firms charge per building. Pennywell charges $5,000 per building for a full audit after a free 48-hour first look.
Is a contingency-fee pharmacy audit free?
No. It costs nothing up front, but you pay a share of everything recovered. When recoveries are large, the share can exceed a flat fee. Compare the dollar totals, not the up-front price.
Do I keep the money that an audit recovers?
With Pennywell, yes: we take no percentage. Your team disputes the charges with our evidence package, and the credits go to you. With a contingency arrangement, you keep what remains after the agreed share.
How long does a pharmacy audit take?
Pennywell's first look is delivered within 48 hours of receiving three files: invoices, census and the pharmacy services agreement. A full audit adds the dispute package for each finding. Approaches that need system setup typically take longer to produce first findings.
Do I have to change pharmacies to get an audit?
No. An audit checks the bills you already receive. Many findings are fixed through disputes and contract changes at renewal, without switching providers.
Get the 48-hour first look
Send three months of invoices, your census and your pharmacy services agreement. Within 48 hours you see what we found and what it is worth, before you pay anything. Request the free 48-hour audit or estimate your number first with the savings calculator.