A nursing home has five pharmacy audit options: review invoices in-house, buy audit software and run it yourself, rely on your pharmacy's own review, hire a recovery-fee firm paid a share of recoveries, or hire a flat-fee audit firm. They differ on three things that matter most: independence from the pharmacy, whether the Part A versus Part D question is checked, and who pays for the work and how. The best choice depends on your staff capacity, your Part A mix and how many buildings you run.
What does a pharmacy audit need to check?
Before comparing options, agree on the job. A pharmacy invoice audit matches every invoice line to three sources: the census (was the resident there, and on which payer?), the pharmacy services agreement (the contract that sets prices, fees and credit rules) and the payer rules (who should have paid for that drug on that day).
The checks, in rough order of dollar impact:
- Payer misbilling: drugs for residents in a covered Part A stay billed to Part D or Medicaid, or the reverse. See who pays for drugs during a Part A stay.
- Charges after discharge, death or leave. See pharmacy charges after discharge, death or leave.
- Duplicates and missing credits for returns and discontinued drugs.
- Fees against contract: dispensing, delivery, emergency kit and IV fees.
- Consolidated billing exclusions: drugs billable outside the Part A rate.
- Price against contract: the discount formula applied to each line.
Our pharmacy invoice audit checklist walks through each one. The payer check matters most for compliance: the OIG opened a review of SNF financial responsibility for drugs for Part D enrollees in Part A stays in April 2025 (OIG Work Plan).
How do the five pharmacy audit options compare?
These describe typical approaches, not specific companies. Any given provider may do more or less.
| Pennywell (audit + monitoring) | Audit software (your team runs it) | Your pharmacy's review | Recovery-fee firms | In-house (business office) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Checks every invoice line against census and contract | Yes | Partly: if your staff run it | Partly: their own review | Yes | Partly: if staff have time |
| No system integration needed | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| First findings in 48 hours | Yes | No: weeks of setup | No | Varies | No |
| Part A / Part D compliance review | Yes | Partly | No | Partly | Partly |
| Independent of your pharmacy | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | Yes |
| Flat, published price | Yes | Partly: often quoted privately | No: bundled in contract | No: share of recoveries | No: staff time |
| You keep 100% of recoveries | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Yes |
| Ready-to-send dispute letters | Yes | Partly | No | Yes | No |
| Monthly tracking dashboard | Yes | Yes | No | No | No |
What could your building recover?
Two numbers, instant estimate. No email needed.
When does each option make sense?
In-house review. Best when you have a strong business office with spare hours and a single building. The cost is hidden in salaries, and the work tends to slip when census is busy or a key person leaves. In-house teams also rarely have the payer-rule depth to test every Part A line.
Audit software. A good fit for larger groups with an analyst who can own it. Software can check volume quickly once data flows in. Someone still has to configure it, investigate exceptions, write disputes and chase credits.
Your pharmacy's review. Many long-term care pharmacies offer cost or "financial value" reports as part of the service. These can be useful for formulary and utilization ideas. They are produced by the party that sent the invoice, so they are not a substitute for an independent check of that invoice.
Recovery-fee firms. Useful when you want no up-front cost and expect large, collectable recoveries. You pay a share of what comes back. Ask how they treat findings that produce no cash, such as Part A exposure, and whether fees apply to future savings.
Flat-fee firms. Best when you want a known cost, independent evidence and to keep every dollar recovered. The risk is paying for an audit that finds little, which a free first look removes. Our article on pharmacy audit cost runs the numbers.
How is Pennywell different?
We are an independent audit firm, and every full audit carries clinical pharmacist sign-off. You send three files: pharmacy invoices, census and your pharmacy services agreement. No system integration. A business associate agreement is signed before any data moves.
- Free 48-hour first look on three months of invoices.
- Full audit, $5,000 per building: a dispute package for each finding, with invoice lines, census evidence, the contract clause and a draft letter.
- Monitoring, $1,000 per building per month: every line every month, credits tracked until paid, and a client dashboard.
We take no percentage of recoveries and no money from pharmacies or manufacturers. Your team sends the disputes; you keep what comes back.
What evidence should any pharmacy audit produce?
Whichever option you choose, judge it by its output. A finding you cannot prove is a finding the pharmacy can decline. Each finding should come with four pieces of evidence:
- The invoice line: date, resident identifier, NDC, quantity, price and fee.
- The census record: where the resident was and which payer applied on that date.
- The contract clause: the price formula, fee schedule or credit term that the line breaks.
- The rule: for payer findings, the coverage rule that decides who should have paid.
Summaries and dashboards are useful for owners. Disputes need line-level evidence. Our guide on how to dispute a pharmacy invoice shows how that evidence becomes a letter.
How do you choose a pharmacy audit option?
- Measure your exposure. Count Part A days and facility-paid drug spend for the last 12 months. High Part A mix means higher stakes; see short-stay and rehab facilities.
- Be honest about staff capacity. Who would run a monthly reconciliation, and how many hours do they have?
- Decide what independence you need. If you need evidence for disputes or a board, the reviewer should not be the pharmacy.
- Require the payer check. Any option that skips Part A versus Part D leaves your largest compliance risk untested.
- Compare total annual cost in dollars, including staff time and any share of recoveries.
- Ask for a sample deliverable. Look for line-level evidence, not a summary.
- Start small. Test with three months of invoices before committing to a long term.
Free · 48 hours · no integration
Get a free 48-hour pharmacy audit
- Send three files: invoices, census, contract
- See overbilling and Part A exposure, line by line
- BAA signed before any data moves
Frequently asked questions
What is the best way to audit nursing home pharmacy invoices?
Match every invoice line to the census, the pharmacy services agreement and the payer rules, and keep line-level evidence for each finding. Who does it matters less than whether all three checks happen every month. Independence from the pharmacy matters when you need to dispute.
Can our pharmacy audit its own invoices?
It can review them, and some offer helpful reports. But it is not independent of the bills, and its review may not test whether drugs it billed to the facility, Part D or Medicaid were billed to the right payer. Use it alongside an independent check, not instead of one.
Is audit software enough on its own?
Only if someone on your team owns it. Software flags exceptions; people still have to investigate them, send disputes and confirm credits arrive. Without that, findings stay on a screen.
How often should a nursing home audit pharmacy invoices?
Every month is ideal, because credit and dispute windows in many agreements are short. At a minimum, review a full quarter before each contract renewal. Monthly monitoring also catches new fee patterns before they compound.
Get the 48-hour first look
The simplest way to compare options is to see real findings on your own invoices. Send three months of invoices, your census and your agreement, and we report back within 48 hours. Get the free 48-hour audit or start with the savings calculator.